This month, I have returned to the world of the graphic novel. This time, I have been reading some classic tales from literature lovingly represented in the Manga style. Both books are ones that I have either never read or never finished for whatever reason so I was glad to have the chance to read these.
This was a beautiful book to read. The art beautifully depicted what life must have been like in England during the 19th Century and the characterisation was fantastic. I read this book with a lot of pleasure, through both the happy and sad times. Pip is one of those characters who you never forget and his love for Estella shines out through the images and speech clearly.
The difficulty with this was the lack of Dickens' feel of the text, from his novels that I have read, but the adaptors have tried their best to get across the style, however hard that may be. I can say that I was not disappointed, however, and it has also made me want to read the original text, maybe later this year, as a full comparison.
Star rating: 4 from 5 - Difficult Dickens made easy
When I tried to read this book last year, I couldn't get beyond the convent scene. For those who read my early reviews last year will know that I found 50 pages of background to be a little too much like hard work! However, this version seemed to skip the background and concentrated on the story at hand, much to my delight.
Again, the art is stunning, and the feel of the story is one of building to a crescendo, which of course it does. Seeing the emotions on the characters faces in certain situations certainly helped with that, and I also found characters to love, some to absolutely hate. Would I now reread the novel? I don't know, to be honest. I really enjoyed the Manga form, but could I sit through Hugo waffling on about how to open the door, or something else like that? We will see. I won't say I won't try it again, because the story itself is wonderful, as this book showed.
Star rating: 4 from 5 - Heavy Hugo lightened
Both of these books are available now!